Cometeer vs Stumptown

Why They Make The Cut?

Cometeer
Cometeer brings a unique flavor profile to the table with a variety of roasts. However, its bulky storage and pricing can be a turn-off for some.
Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew
Stumptown's Original Cold Brew with OATLY stands out for its perfect balance of flavor, convenience, and sustainability. It's a premium product that delivers on taste and ethical production.

Review Summary

Cometeer
Cometeer offers a flavorful coffee experience with a wide range of roasts. Its unique storing method and taste make it a distinct choice.
Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew
Stumptown's Original Cold Brew with OATLY offers a premium cold brew experience with a perfect balance of flavor and convenience. Its partnership with Oatly and commitment to sustainability add value beyond taste.

Flavor Profile

Cometeer

So, let’s go ahead and start with the most important part, the taste.

You might have experienced “pod coffee” (like what you get in a K-cup) that tastes watered down, acidic, or like expired coffee. However, when I first tried Cometeer, I was pleasantly surprised. The second I peeled off the cap on the aluminum capsule, a fresh coffee aroma washed over me…

And considering the fact that Cometeer freeze dries their coffee, I was VERY surprised. (As a side note, I don’t like the freeze drying process, because some studies show that it can introduce harmful chemicals into the coffee. But I can’t make any specific claims on that here).  

Cometeer also claim that their coffee is “hyper fresh” and “the world’s best coffee.” And while I can’t say if those claims are true, I can tell you that Cometeer smells like, and also tastes like fresh coffee.

Because the moment I tasted my first cup of Cometeer Coffee, I can tell you that it was one of the better instant/convenient coffees that I tried. It was WAY better than any type of instant coffee, or even K cups. And the only other coffee that I think might have an edge, is a coffee concentrate.

Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

The flavor profile of Stumptown's Original Cold Brew with OATLY is smooth, rich, and well-balanced. The cold brew coffee provides a robust base with notes of chocolate and subtle fruitiness, while the Oatly oat milk adds a creamy texture and slight sweetness without overpowering the coffee. The result is a harmonious blend that's not too sweet, allowing the nuances of the coffee to shine through.

Flavor Notes

Cometeer
  • Fresh coffee aroma
  • Superior to instant coffee and K-cups
  • Premium taste profile
  • Not watered down
  • No acidic aftertaste
  • Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew
  • Smooth and rich
  • Chocolate notes
  • Subtle fruitiness
  • Creamy texture
  • Not too sweet
  • Balanced taste
  • Caffeine Content

    Cometeer

    At least for their Apollo, Birch, and Mocha Java roasts, each of the Cometeer capsules have 180mg of caffeine. Now, in my personal opinion, I think that’s a little bit too much for you to have in a single cup of coffee…

    And that’s because the average cup of coffee only has about 95mg of caffeine. So when you start making your coffee with Cometeer, you’re giving yourself A LOT more caffeine. And that means if you’re not used to taking that much caffeine, you could feel an extra strong buzz, get the jitters, or even desensitize yourself to normal coffee.

    But for some of you guys who need an EXTRA big boost, you might like having that much caffeine. However, if you’re trying to limit your caffeine intake, or you don’t want to ruin regular coffee for yourself, maybe you’ll be better off opting for a solution with lower caffeine.

    Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

    Stumptown's Original Cold Brew with OATLY contains caffeine equivalent to 8 oz of cold brew, which is about 1.5 cups of drip coffee. This provides a solid energy boost without being overpowering, making it suitable for those who need a pick-me-up but don't want the jitters associated with higher caffeine content.

    Convenience Factor

    Cometeer

    Okay, here’s what’s very unique about Cometeer…

    They basically took K-cups to the next level. And that’s because when you order a case of Cometeer capsules, you’ll get something that looks like normal K cups. However, with these, you don’t need any sort of machine to turn them into coffee.

    All you have to do is add the freeze-dried capsule into a cup of hot or cold water. And the coffee will immediately melt, mix with the water, and give you fresh-tasting coffee in seconds. Honestly, this is pretty darn cool to use, but there is a significant cost…

    Just like with K-cups, making all of your coffee with Cometeer is pretty wasteful. And while the company does use recyclable aluminum to make the pods, there’s no telling what these recycling companies actually do with the aluminum. For all we know, they could be stockpiling them in landfills and not actually recycling them! That’s just my personal opinion, but if you’re environmentally conscious at all, just take that into consideration.

    Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

    Convenience is a strong point for this product. The 11 oz carton is ready to drink, requiring no preparation or additional ingredients. It's perfect for busy mornings, on-the-go situations, or when you want a quick and easy cold brew fix. The compact size also makes it easy to store in the fridge or pack in a bag.

    Ease of Use

    Cometeer

    Using the Cometeer Pods is very simple, it only takes me a few minutes to make my coffee in the morning. And over the past few weeks, I realized how much time I was wasting in the morning on brewing coffee, or even driving to Starbucks.

    And compared to regular Keurig machines, these pods are MUCH easier to use. And these are also perfect for making your coffee when camping (especially since you don’t need electricity or a big bulky machine).

    Also, another great selling point for Cometeer Pods, is you can make any of your favorite hot or cold drinks. Compared to other types of cold brew or instant coffee- you can’t always say the same thing.

    Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

    Stumptown's Original Cold Brew with OATLY is extremely easy to use. There's no need for brewing, mixing, or measuring - simply shake the carton, open, and pour. This simplicity makes it accessible to anyone, regardless of their coffee-making skills or available time.

    Scoring Breakdown

    Coffee

    Cometeer

    Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

    Photo
    Cometeer Coffee
    Stumptown Original Cold Brew with OATLY
    Taste
    8
    9
    Value
    6
    6
    Convenience
    9
    10
    Packaging
    7
    9
    Overall
    7
    8

    Attribute Ratings

    Origin

    Cometeer

    Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

    Caffeine Amount
    7
    8
    Convenience
    5
    9
    Ease of Use
    6
    10
    Flavor Profile
    8
    9
    Customer Service
    8
    8

    Quick Facts

    Cometeer
  • Freeze-dried coffee capsules
  • 180mg caffeine per capsule
  • Recyclable aluminum pods
  • $64/month subscription
  • Requires freezer storage
  • Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew
  • 11 oz carton size
  • 100% recyclable packaging
  • 53% renewable material
  • Equivalent to 1.5 cups of drip coffee
  • Partnership with Oatly
  • $5 per carton
  • Recommended Preparations

    Cometeer

    Can be used for both hot and cold coffee preparations. Simply add the freeze-dried capsule to hot or cold water for instant preparation. Ideal for regular coffee drinks and suitable for camping or travel use.

    Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

    Ready to drink straight from the carton. Simply shake well before consuming. Can be enjoyed cold or over ice.

    Ideal For

    Cometeer
  • Busy professionals
  • Camping enthusiasts
  • Coffee lovers seeking convenience
  • Those who prefer stronger caffeine content
  • People who value quick preparation
  • Travelers
  • Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew
  • Busy professionals
  • On-the-go coffee lovers
  • Eco-conscious consumers
  • Cold brew enthusiasts
  • Those who prefer dairy alternatives
  • Morning commuters
  • Pros and Cons

    Cometeer Coffee

    Pros
    • Tasty flavor profile
    • Variety of roasts to choose from
    • Good customer service
    Cons
    • Bulky to store at home (stores in freezer)
    • Expensive pricing $64/month
    • Just as time consuming as making a normal cup of coffee

    Stumptown Original Cold Brew with OATLY

    Pros
    • Smooth, balanced flavor
    • Convenient ready-to-drink format
    • Sustainable packaging
    • Vegan and low sugar
    Cons
    • Higher price point
    • Limited size options
    • May not suit those who prefer stronger coffee

    Which Should You Choose?

    FAQs