Grady's vs Stumptown

Why They Make The Cut?

Grady's Cold Brew
Grady's Cold Brew stands out with its unique New Orleans-Style flavor and convenient concentrate format, catering to health-conscious coffee lovers with its all-natural ingredients.
Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew
Stumptown's Original Cold Brew with OATLY stands out for its perfect balance of flavor, convenience, and sustainability. It's a premium product that delivers on taste and ethical production.

Review Summary

Grady's Cold Brew
Grady's Cold Brew offers a premium, New Orleans-Style cold brew concentrate with a unique flavor profile, convenience, and all-natural ingredients, making it a top choice for cold brew enthusiasts.
Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew
Stumptown's Original Cold Brew with OATLY offers a premium cold brew experience with a perfect balance of flavor and convenience. Its partnership with Oatly and commitment to sustainability add value beyond taste.

Flavor Profile

Grady's Cold Brew

Grady's Cold Brew offers a unique flavor profile that sets it apart from other cold brews. The New Orleans-Style blend, infused with chicory and spices, creates a rich, smooth taste that's both bold and nuanced. Many customers rave about its velvety texture and the fact that it's enjoyable even without added milk or sugar.

The flavor is described as robust yet smooth, with no bitter aftertaste often associated with cold brews. The addition of chicory adds a subtle depth to the coffee, while the proprietary blend of spices contributes to its distinctive taste without overpowering the coffee notes.

Customers particularly appreciate the consistency of flavor across batches, indicating Grady's commitment to quality control in their brewing process.

Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

The flavor profile of Stumptown's Original Cold Brew with OATLY is smooth, rich, and well-balanced. The cold brew coffee provides a robust base with notes of chocolate and subtle fruitiness, while the Oatly oat milk adds a creamy texture and slight sweetness without overpowering the coffee. The result is a harmonious blend that's not too sweet, allowing the nuances of the coffee to shine through.

Flavor Notes

Grady's Cold Brew
  • Velvety-smooth texture
  • Rich and bold coffee base
  • Chicory undertones
  • Subtle spice blend
  • No bitter aftertaste
  • Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew
  • Smooth and rich
  • Chocolate notes
  • Subtle fruitiness
  • Creamy texture
  • Not too sweet
  • Balanced taste
  • Caffeine Content

    Grady's Cold Brew

    While Grady's doesn't explicitly state the caffeine content on their packaging or website, cold brew coffee generally contains more caffeine than regular brewed coffee due to its concentrated nature. Based on customer reviews, the caffeine kick from Grady's Cold Brew is substantial, providing a strong energy boost.

    It's important to note that the caffeine content can be adjusted based on how you dilute the concentrate. This flexibility allows users to control their caffeine intake according to their preferences and tolerance levels.

    For those sensitive to caffeine or looking to monitor their intake, it would be beneficial if Grady's provided more specific information about the caffeine content in their product.

    Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

    Stumptown's Original Cold Brew with OATLY contains caffeine equivalent to 8 oz of cold brew, which is about 1.5 cups of drip coffee. This provides a solid energy boost without being overpowering, making it suitable for those who need a pick-me-up but don't want the jitters associated with higher caffeine content.

    Convenience Factor

    Grady's Cold Brew

    Grady's Cold Brew scores high on convenience. The concentrate format allows for easy storage and quick preparation of coffee drinks. Each 32 oz bottle provides multiple servings, reducing the need for frequent purchases.

    The fact that it's readily available for home delivery or in many grocery stores adds to its convenience factor. Customers appreciate the ability to have their favorite cold brew on hand without the need to visit a coffee shop.

    The concentrate's versatility is another convenience factor. It can be used to make both hot and cold coffee drinks, catering to different preferences and seasons.

    However, the need for refrigeration before and after opening might be a slight inconvenience for some, especially when traveling or in situations where refrigeration isn't readily available.

    Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

    Convenience is a strong point for this product. The 11 oz carton is ready to drink, requiring no preparation or additional ingredients. It's perfect for busy mornings, on-the-go situations, or when you want a quick and easy cold brew fix. The compact size also makes it easy to store in the fridge or pack in a bag.

    Ease of Use

    Grady's Cold Brew

    Grady's Cold Brew is designed for easy use. The concentrate format allows for simple preparation - just mix with water or milk according to your taste preference. This ease of use is particularly appreciated by customers who want a quick, hassle-free coffee experience.

    The product comes with clear instructions on the recommended ratios for mixing, making it easy even for those new to cold brew concentrates. The ability to adjust the strength by varying the amount of concentrate used adds to its user-friendly nature.

    One potential area for improvement could be providing more detailed guidelines or recipes for various coffee drinks that can be made with the concentrate, which would enhance the user experience further.

    Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

    Stumptown's Original Cold Brew with OATLY is extremely easy to use. There's no need for brewing, mixing, or measuring - simply shake the carton, open, and pour. This simplicity makes it accessible to anyone, regardless of their coffee-making skills or available time.

    Scoring Breakdown

    Coffee

    Grady's Cold Brew

    Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

    Photo
    Grady's Cold Brew
    Stumptown Original Cold Brew with OATLY
    Taste
    9
    9
    Value
    8
    6
    Convenience
    9
    10
    Packaging
    8
    9
    Overall
    9
    8

    Attribute Ratings

    Origin

    Grady's Cold Brew

    Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

    Caffeine Amount
    8
    8
    Convenience
    9
    9
    Ease of Use
    9
    10
    Flavor Profile
    9
    9
    Customer Service
    8
    8

    Quick Facts

    Grady's Cold Brew
  • Founded in 2011
  • New Orleans-Style cold brew concentrate
  • 20-hour brewing process
  • 32 oz bottle makes 8 (8 oz) servings
  • All-natural, sugar-free, vegan, low calorie
  • Non-GMO, kosher, gluten-free
  • Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew
  • 11 oz carton size
  • 100% recyclable packaging
  • 53% renewable material
  • Equivalent to 1.5 cups of drip coffee
  • Partnership with Oatly
  • $5 per carton
  • Recommended Preparations

    Grady's Cold Brew
    Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew

    Ready to drink straight from the carton. Simply shake well before consuming. Can be enjoyed cold or over ice.

    Ideal For

    Grady's Cold Brew
  • Health-conscious coffee lovers
  • Busy professionals
  • Cold brew enthusiasts
  • Dietary-restricted individuals
  • Those who appreciate craft coffee
  • Hot and cold coffee drinkers
  • Stumptown Coffee Roasters Cold Brew
  • Busy professionals
  • On-the-go coffee lovers
  • Eco-conscious consumers
  • Cold brew enthusiasts
  • Those who prefer dairy alternatives
  • Morning commuters
  • Pros and Cons

    Grady's Cold Brew

    Pros
    • Unique New Orleans-Style flavor
    • All-natural and dietary-friendly
    • Convenient concentrate format
    • Versatile for hot and cold drinks
    Cons
    • Lack of specific caffeine content information
    • Requires refrigeration
    • Limited recipe suggestions

    Stumptown Original Cold Brew with OATLY

    Pros
    • Smooth, balanced flavor
    • Convenient ready-to-drink format
    • Sustainable packaging
    • Vegan and low sugar
    Cons
    • Higher price point
    • Limited size options
    • May not suit those who prefer stronger coffee

    Which Should You Choose?

    FAQs